Eggplants are always purple. John bought a purple vegetable. Therefore, it was an eggplant.
Which of the following arguments contains reasoning most similar to the flawed reasoning in the above argument?
Except for 2, prime numbers are always odd. The number 13 is odd. Therefore, it is prime.
Rabbits are fast creatures. A fast creature ran by. Therefore, it may have been a rabbit.
Bluebirds are not always blue. A brown bird was outside the window. Therefore, it may or may not have been a blue bird.
Gambling is a risky hobby. Jamie likes taking risks. Therefore, she likes to gamble.
Jenny always eats healthy. Salmon is a healthy food. Therefore, she eats salmon.