In a physics class, students conducted a series of experiments by placing different objects into a beaker of water. They conducted twenty trials for each object. For each trial, they recorded whether or not the object floated.

First, they placed a steel paper clip into the water. They observed that the paper clip usually sank; however, they also saw that occasionally, the paper clip stayed afloat if it was placed very gently on top of the water. Next, they repeated the the same procedure using a cork, a toy boat made of aluminum, and a glass marble. They observed that both the cork and the toy boat always stayed afloat in the water, but that the glass marble always sank.

Below, three students give their explanations for these observations.

Student 1:

Objects float when they are less dense than the liquid in which they are immersed. For example, when immiscible liquids of varying densities are mixed together in a container, the most dense liquid will sink to the bottom of the container, while the least dense liquid will rise to the top. This same principle applies to solid objects. Because the cork and the aluminum toy boat always float, cork and the aluminum of the boat must be less dense than water. Because the glass marble always sinks, the glass of the marble must be more dense than water.

Objects that are more dense than water can also float due to surface tension. Surface tension occurs because molecules of a liquid are more attracted to each other more than they are to other objects. Molecules on the surface of water are attracted to the molecules around them and below them. This attraction causes a liquid's surface to behave if it were covered by a thin film, which resists penetration by other objects. Therefore, small objects such as paper clips can sometimes float on water when the upward force of water's surface tension exceeds the force of gravity pulling such objects down. Because the paper clips often sink and only float sometimes, we can conclude that they are indeed more dense than water, and that their floating is due to surface tension.

Student 2:

Objects float in two different cases: when they are buoyed by a liquid's surface tension or when their average density is less than that of the liquid in which they are immersed. The average density of cork is less than that of water. This is why the cork floats. In contrast, the density of glass is more than that of water. This is why the glass marble sinks.

However, the densities of aluminum and of steel are greater than that of water. Thus, density cannot be used to explain why the aluminum toy boat and the paper clip float. Both of these objects float because of surface tension. Because the paper clip does not have much mass, the normal upward force created by water's surface tension can be enough to allow it to float. Other objects with greater mass, like the toy boat, employ a particular shape to magnify the force of surface tension. The curved shape of the boat's bottom both stabilizes the boat and increases the amount of the boat's surface area that touches the water, maximizing the force due to surface tension that the boat receives.

Student 3:

In this experiment, the paper clip floats because of surface tension; however, the cork, toy boat, and marble float or sink because of their relationship to a buoyant force. All objects immersed in a liquid experience a buoyant force, which pushes them upward. The strength of this force is equal to the weight of the liquid displaced, or pushed aside, by an object. Every object also experiences a downward force due to gravity, which is measured as the object's weight, and which is directly proportional to the object's mass. When the buoyant force acting on an object is greater than the downward force due to gravity, the object floats. However, when the buoyant force is less than the force due to gravity, the object sinks. Both the cork and the aluminum toy boat are able to displace enough water to create a buoyant force that exceeds the force due to gravity, so they float. However, the glass marble does not displace enough water to create a sufficient buoyant force, so it sinks.

The density of fresh, newly cut wood is less than water, and fresh wood always floats; however, over time, floating pieces of wood may sink. Which of the following explanations would Student 1 most likely give for this observation?

In a physics class, students conducted a series of experiments by placing different objects into a beaker of water. They conducted twenty trials for each object. For each trial, they recorded whether or not the object floated.

First, they placed a steel paper clip into the water. They observed that the paper clip usually sank; however, they also saw that occasionally, the paper clip stayed afloat if it was placed very gently on top of the water. Next, they repeated the the same procedure using a cork, a toy boat made of aluminum, and a glass marble. They observed that both the cork and the toy boat always stayed afloat in the water, but that the glass marble always sank.

Below, three students give their explanations for these observations.

Student 1:

Objects float when they are less dense than the liquid in which they are immersed. For example, when immiscible liquids of varying densities are mixed together in a container, the most dense liquid will sink to the bottom of the container, while the least dense liquid will rise to the top. This same principle applies to solid objects. Because the cork and the aluminum toy boat always float, cork and the aluminum of the boat must be less dense than water. Because the glass marble always sinks, the glass of the marble must be more dense than water.

Objects that are more dense than water can also float due to surface tension. Surface tension occurs because molecules of a liquid are more attracted to each other more than they are to other objects. Molecules on the surface of water are attracted to the molecules around them and below them. This attraction causes a liquid's surface to behave if it were covered by a thin film, which resists penetration by other objects. Therefore, small objects such as paper clips can sometimes float on water when the upward force of water's surface tension exceeds the force of gravity pulling such objects down. Because the paper clips often sink and only float sometimes, we can conclude that they are indeed more dense than water, and that their floating is due to surface tension.

Student 2:

Objects float in two different cases: when they are buoyed by a liquid's surface tension or when their average density is less than that of the liquid in which they are immersed. The average density of cork is less than that of water. This is why the cork floats. In contrast, the density of glass is more than that of water. This is why the glass marble sinks.

However, the densities of aluminum and of steel are greater than that of water. Thus, density cannot be used to explain why the aluminum toy boat and the paper clip float. Both of these objects float because of surface tension. Because the paper clip does not have much mass, the normal upward force created by water's surface tension can be enough to allow it to float. Other objects with greater mass, like the toy boat, employ a particular shape to magnify the force of surface tension. The curved shape of the boat's bottom both stabilizes the boat and increases the amount of the boat's surface area that touches the water, maximizing the force due to surface tension that the boat receives.

Student 3:

In this experiment, the paper clip floats because of surface tension; however, the cork, toy boat, and marble float or sink because of their relationship to a buoyant force. All objects immersed in a liquid experience a buoyant force, which pushes them upward. The strength of this force is equal to the weight of the liquid displaced, or pushed aside, by an object. Every object also experiences a downward force due to gravity, which is measured as the object's weight, and which is directly proportional to the object's mass. When the buoyant force acting on an object is greater than the downward force due to gravity, the object floats. However, when the buoyant force is less than the force due to gravity, the object sinks. Both the cork and the aluminum toy boat are able to displace enough water to create a buoyant force that exceeds the force due to gravity, so they float. However, the glass marble does not displace enough water to create a sufficient buoyant force, so it sinks.

The density of fresh, newly cut wood is less than water, and fresh wood always floats; however, over time, floating pieces of wood may sink. Which of the following explanations would Student 1 most likely give for this observation?

Scientist 1: Scientist 1 believes that light displays particle behavior. This means that rays of light have their own associated momentum. Furthermore, Scientist 1 does not believe that light will exhibit wave behavior.

Scientist 2: Scientist 2 disagrees with Scientist 1 and believes that light can exhibit wave behavior, but does not display particle behavior. In other words, this scientist believes that light does not have any momentum.

Experiment: To settle their disagreement, the scientists setup the following experiment. The scientist take dark metallic material. This material is attached to pole and the metallic material can spin if it is subjected to a force; similar to a watermill or wind turbine. This setup is then placed outside and exposed to sunlight.

Assuming that sunlight displays particle behavior, what is the best way to design a device to absorb solar energy and turn it into electrical energy?

Scientist 1: This scientist claims that the current in a circuit flows from the positive side of a battery to the negative side of the battery. In other words, the protons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Scientist 2: This scientist asserts that the current in a circuit flows from the negative side of a battery to the positive side of the battery. In other words, the electrons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Experiment A: The scientists construct a circuit that contains just a battery, a switch and light bulb. The wiring is made of copper. The scientists turn the switch from off to on. It is noticed that the light bulb turns on.

Experiment B: The scientists have developed a novel metal that allows for only electrons to travel through the metal, but does not allow protons to travel through the metal. The scientists construct the same circuit as in Experiment A, using this material as the wiring. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb turns on.

Experiment C: The scientists have also constructed a metal that allows for only protons to travel through the metal, but does not allow for electrons to travel through the metal. The same circuit as in Experiment A is constructed, but with the wiring being made by this innovative metal. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb does not turn on.

Whose viewpoints are supported or disproved by Experiment C?

Scientist 1: This scientist claims that the current in a circuit flows from the positive side of a battery to the negative side of the battery. In other words, the protons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Scientist 2: This scientist asserts that the current in a circuit flows from the negative side of a battery to the positive side of the battery. In other words, the electrons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Experiment A: The scientists construct a circuit that contains just a battery, a switch and light bulb. The wiring is made of copper. The scientists turn the switch from off to on. It is noticed that the light bulb turns on.

Experiment B: The scientists have developed a novel metal that allows for only electrons to travel through the metal, but does not allow protons to travel through the metal. The scientists construct the same circuit as in Experiment A, using this material as the wiring. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb turns on.

Experiment C: The scientists have also constructed a metal that allows for only protons to travel through the metal, but does not allow for electrons to travel through the metal. The same circuit as in Experiment A is constructed, but with the wiring being made by this innovative metal. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb does not turn on.

Whose viewpoint(s) does Experiment B support or disprove?

Sound waves travel through a medium by mechanically disturbing the particles of that medium. As particles in the medium are displaced by the sound wave, they in turn act upon neighboring particles. In this fashion, the wave travels through the medium through a parallel series of disturbed particles. Like in other forms of motion, the rate at which the sound wave travels can be measured by dividing the distance over which the wave travels by the time required for it to do so.

Study 1
A group of students hypothesizes that the velocity of sound is dependent upon the density of the medium through which it passes. They propose that with more matter in a given space, each particle needs to travel a shorter distance to disturb the adjacent particles. Using two microphones and a high speed recording device, the students measured the delay from the first microphone to the second. They chose a variety of media, shown in Table 1, and measured the velocity of sound through each using their two-microphone setup. The results are found in Table 1.

Study 2
The students wanted to test their hypothesis by using the same medium at different densities. To do this, they heated pure water to various temperatures and repeated the procedure described in Study 1. Their results can be found in Table 2.

According to Study 2, water at which of the following temperatures yields the greatest velocity of sound?

In a physics class, students conducted a series of experiments by placing different objects into a beaker of water. They conducted twenty trials for each object. For each trial, they recorded whether or not the object floated.

First, they placed a steel paper clip into the water. They observed that the paper clip usually sank; however, they also saw that occasionally, the paper clip stayed afloat if it was placed very gently on top of the water. Next, they repeated the the same procedure using a cork, a toy boat made of aluminum, and a glass marble. They observed that both the cork and the toy boat always stayed afloat in the water, but that the glass marble always sank.

Below, three students give their explanations for these observations.

Student 1:

Objects float when they are less dense than the liquid in which they are immersed. For example, when immiscible liquids of varying densities are mixed together in a container, the most dense liquid will sink to the bottom of the container, while the least dense liquid will rise to the top. This same principle applies to solid objects. Because the cork and the aluminum toy boat always float, cork and the aluminum of the boat must be less dense than water. Because the glass marble always sinks, the glass of the marble must be more dense than water.

Objects that are more dense than water can also float due to surface tension. Surface tension occurs because molecules of a liquid are more attracted to each other more than they are to other objects. Molecules on the surface of water are attracted to the molecules around them and below them. This attraction causes a liquid's surface to behave if it were covered by a thin film, which resists penetration by other objects. Therefore, small objects such as paper clips can sometimes float on water when the upward force of water's surface tension exceeds the force of gravity pulling such objects down. Because the paper clips often sink and only float sometimes, we can conclude that they are indeed more dense than water, and that their floating is due to surface tension.

Student 2:

Objects float in two different cases: when they are buoyed by a liquid's surface tension or when their average density is less than that of the liquid in which they are immersed. The average density of cork is less than that of water. This is why the cork floats. In contrast, the density of glass is more than that of water. This is why the glass marble sinks.

However, the densities of aluminum and of steel are greater than that of water. Thus, density cannot be used to explain why the aluminum toy boat and the paper clip float. Both of these objects float because of surface tension. Because the paper clip does not have much mass, the normal upward force created by water's surface tension can be enough to allow it to float. Other objects with greater mass, like the toy boat, employ a particular shape to magnify the force of surface tension. The curved shape of the boat's bottom both stabilizes the boat and increases the amount of the boat's surface area that touches the water, maximizing the force due to surface tension that the boat receives.

Student 3:

In this experiment, the paper clip floats because of surface tension; however, the cork, toy boat, and marble float or sink because of their relationship to a buoyant force. All objects immersed in a liquid experience a buoyant force, which pushes them upward. The strength of this force is equal to the weight of the liquid displaced, or pushed aside, by an object. Every object also experiences a downward force due to gravity, which is measured as the object's weight, and which is directly proportional to the object's mass. When the buoyant force acting on an object is greater than the downward force due to gravity, the object floats. However, when the buoyant force is less than the force due to gravity, the object sinks. Both the cork and the aluminum toy boat are able to displace enough water to create a buoyant force that exceeds the force due to gravity, so they float. However, the glass marble does not displace enough water to create a sufficient buoyant force, so it sinks.

A surfactant is a substance that reduces the surface tension of the liquid to which it is added. Laundry detergent is a surfactant. If Student 3's explanation is correct, how likely will a paper clip placed in water with laundry detergent be to float, compared to a paper clip placed in water without laundry detergent? The paper clip in water with laundry detergent is __________.

In a physics class, students conducted a series of experiments by placing different objects into a beaker of water. They conducted twenty trials for each object. For each trial, they recorded whether or not the object floated.

First, they placed a steel paper clip into the water. They observed that the paper clip usually sank; however, they also saw that occasionally, the paper clip stayed afloat if it was placed very gently on top of the water. Next, they repeated the the same procedure using a cork, a toy boat made of aluminum, and a glass marble. They observed that both the cork and the toy boat always stayed afloat in the water, but that the glass marble always sank.

Below, three students give their explanations for these observations.

Student 1:

Objects float when they are less dense than the liquid in which they are immersed. For example, when immiscible liquids of varying densities are mixed together in a container, the most dense liquid will sink to the bottom of the container, while the least dense liquid will rise to the top. This same principle applies to solid objects. Because the cork and the aluminum toy boat always float, cork and the aluminum of the boat must be less dense than water. Because the glass marble always sinks, the glass of the marble must be more dense than water.

Objects that are more dense than water can also float due to surface tension. Surface tension occurs because molecules of a liquid are more attracted to each other more than they are to other objects. Molecules on the surface of water are attracted to the molecules around them and below them. This attraction causes a liquid's surface to behave if it were covered by a thin film, which resists penetration by other objects. Therefore, small objects such as paper clips can sometimes float on water when the upward force of water's surface tension exceeds the force of gravity pulling such objects down. Because the paper clips often sink and only float sometimes, we can conclude that they are indeed more dense than water, and that their floating is due to surface tension.

Student 2:

Objects float in two different cases: when they are buoyed by a liquid's surface tension or when their average density is less than that of the liquid in which they are immersed. The average density of cork is less than that of water. This is why the cork floats. In contrast, the density of glass is more than that of water. This is why the glass marble sinks.

However, the densities of aluminum and of steel are greater than that of water. Thus, density cannot be used to explain why the aluminum toy boat and the paper clip float. Both of these objects float because of surface tension. Because the paper clip does not have much mass, the normal upward force created by water's surface tension can be enough to allow it to float. Other objects with greater mass, like the toy boat, employ a particular shape to magnify the force of surface tension. The curved shape of the boat's bottom both stabilizes the boat and increases the amount of the boat's surface area that touches the water, maximizing the force due to surface tension that the boat receives.

Student 3:

In this experiment, the paper clip floats because of surface tension; however, the cork, toy boat, and marble float or sink because of their relationship to a buoyant force. All objects immersed in a liquid experience a buoyant force, which pushes them upward. The strength of this force is equal to the weight of the liquid displaced, or pushed aside, by an object. Every object also experiences a downward force due to gravity, which is measured as the object's weight, and which is directly proportional to the object's mass. When the buoyant force acting on an object is greater than the downward force due to gravity, the object floats. However, when the buoyant force is less than the force due to gravity, the object sinks. Both the cork and the aluminum toy boat are able to displace enough water to create a buoyant force that exceeds the force due to gravity, so they float. However, the glass marble does not displace enough water to create a sufficient buoyant force, so it sinks.

Paint is more dense than cooking oil; however, when a drop of paint is dripped into a container of cooking oil, it floats on top of the oil. If Student 1's explanation is correct, which of the following is most likely the reason for this observation?

Scientist 1: This scientist claims that the current in a circuit flows from the positive side of a battery to the negative side of the battery. In other words, the protons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Scientist 2: This scientist asserts that the current in a circuit flows from the negative side of a battery to the positive side of the battery. In other words, the electrons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Experiment A: The scientists construct a circuit that contains just a battery, a switch and light bulb. The wiring is made of copper. The scientists turn the switch from off to on. It is noticed that the light bulb turns on.

Experiment B: The scientists have developed a novel metal that allows for only electrons to travel through the metal, but does not allow protons to travel through the metal. The scientists construct the same circuit as in Experiment A, using this material as the wiring. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb turns on.

Experiment C: The scientists have also constructed a metal that allows for only protons to travel through the metal, but does not allow for electrons to travel through the metal. The same circuit as in Experiment A is constructed, but with the wiring being made by this innovative metal. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb does not turn on.

Whose viewpoints are supported or disproved by Experiment C?

Scientist 1: This scientist claims that the current in a circuit flows from the positive side of a battery to the negative side of the battery. In other words, the protons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Scientist 2: This scientist asserts that the current in a circuit flows from the negative side of a battery to the positive side of the battery. In other words, the electrons in the circuit are responsible for the flow of electricity.

Experiment A: The scientists construct a circuit that contains just a battery, a switch and light bulb. The wiring is made of copper. The scientists turn the switch from off to on. It is noticed that the light bulb turns on.

Experiment B: The scientists have developed a novel metal that allows for only electrons to travel through the metal, but does not allow protons to travel through the metal. The scientists construct the same circuit as in Experiment A, using this material as the wiring. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb turns on.

Experiment C: The scientists have also constructed a metal that allows for only protons to travel through the metal, but does not allow for electrons to travel through the metal. The same circuit as in Experiment A is constructed, but with the wiring being made by this innovative metal. When the switch is turned on, the light bulb does not turn on.

Whose viewpoint(s) does Experiment B support or disprove?